Mud-club

Vehicle & Technical => Discovery => Topic started by: muddyjames on February 09, 2006, 14:28:13

Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 09, 2006, 14:28:13
I have bought a cb radio and hope to mount the aerial onto the roof bars, you know the ones. they go front to back on both sides of the disco and the other pieces clip into them.

I am hoping that they will be a good earth for the aerial. I am guessing they are bolted onto the disco as you can rock the car and they stay put! So in theory they should be ok.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: TimM on February 09, 2006, 14:44:30
Hmmmm, not sure.

I have a feeling they are Aluminium, and I have visions of seeing some sort of padding between the roof and the bar.

Why do you want to mount it there?
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: thermidorthelobster on February 09, 2006, 15:21:24
I think they're steel bars with ally end mouldings, but that's not really relevant as both steel and ally conduct electricity very well of course.

The question is how they bolt through.  There is foam padding between the ally pieces and the roof, but I imagine the bolts which hold them to the roof are not insulated from the roof.  But I've never taken the head lining out, so I'm not sure.

Stick a multimeter on and you'll find out pretty quickly.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: TimM on February 09, 2006, 15:25:10
Quote from: "thermidorthelobster"
I think they're steel bars with ally end mouldings, but that's not really relevant as both steel and ally conduct electricity very well of course.


That sounds about right, but I thought Aluminium wasn't a very good groundplane (for the CB).

I could be wrong though  :?
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 09, 2006, 15:37:43
Quote from: "TimM"


Why do you want to mount it there?


Coz I bought a quickly removeable aerial holder as I want to take the whole cb radio indoors when not in use or put it into another car if needs to be. I dont want the aerial on show as light fingers may want to pinch it and or break in and steel anything elseinside they like the look of.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: NeilWilson on February 09, 2006, 15:39:10
Quote from: "thermidorthelobster"
Stick a multimeter on and you'll find out pretty quickly.


Just checked on mine and the bars are earthed (or if you prefer, negative terminal connected).

Neil
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 09, 2006, 15:40:29
cool wicked. thats a good start. just hope my roof mount grips now!
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Tyke on February 09, 2006, 15:45:42
You need good bare metal contact when dealing with earths on radio equipment. We are dealing with RF currents at very high frequencies and what is fine for a DC system may offer such a high impedence to the flow of RF current that a normal DC earth may be all but useless.

Doubt that the roof bars would provide a good enough earth for efficient working of the radio. This could show up later as very high SWR readings when you are setting up the system and in severe cases, operating with high SWR's can cause heat build up in the radio set and effectively burn out the output transistors.

Don't worry too much though, just take advice from the guys who have them fitted and working ok . there's loads on here.

All bit complicated if you are not into radios but here is a site that may help you understand a little better.

http://www.k2bj.com/Ground.htm
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: NeilWilson on February 09, 2006, 15:59:26
Quote from: "Tyke"
You need good bare metal contact when dealing with earths on radio equipment


True enough, although lots of people get away with mounts on roofracks with rubber gutter feet ends and various other mechanical contraptions.  You can counteract some of the SWR with suitable aerial tuning.  Any earth is going to be better than none at all.  I have mine mounted on the spare wheel carrier.

Neil
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 09, 2006, 16:01:34
how do you mount yours Niel? I thought about that but my spare wheel has the grey plastic trim on it and i cant be bothered to take that on and off after every trip or unless it will mount on and then leave on and be hard for light fingers to take of I may leave it thee.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: NeilWilson on February 09, 2006, 16:11:26
Small bracket, close to the door but not not too close to foul the rear wiper.  Then the cable through a hole in the door and around the top side of the trim to the CB on the dash.  

Based it on an article in http://www.expeditionexchange.com/cbantenna/

Neil
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Tyke on February 09, 2006, 16:31:31
Quote
You can counteract some of the SWR with suitable aerial tuning


Thats true mate. I didn't want to start frightening people but as long as we are aware of what we are doing we usually get by. There may be a loss in efficiency of the set due to the high SWR's but considering cb's are generaly used on 4x4's for local comms then we aint looking for finely tuned DX type transmissions.


Just to get things back into perspective, I used to contact the States regularily on the older, illegal,  27Mhz AM with a quarter wave mobile antennae stuck in the middle of a biscuit tin when the skip was good during the peak sunspot cycles - was doing better than the local Ham on his 150w HF rig  :lol:


So we dont have to worry too much about fitting them to vehicles  :wink:
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: NeilWilson on February 09, 2006, 16:54:58
That is a pretty good skip by any definition, what was the rx quality like ?

Neil
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: hobbit on February 09, 2006, 17:54:36
Aluminium is a better conductor than steel, that is what the expensive wire is made from
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Damonski on February 09, 2006, 18:37:38
I recall from reading various other posts that fitting those is not the easiest job in the world  :(
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: landraver on February 09, 2006, 19:32:09
Quote from: "hobbit"
Aluminium is a better conductor than steel, that is what the expensive wire is made from


Thats right Kev, in fact, weight for weight, its a far better conductor than copper!

Jeff
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 09, 2006, 19:33:01
so i could be in with a chance then?
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Range Rover Blues on February 09, 2006, 21:15:23
A CB ariel needs a decent ground plane ie a large flat bit of steel.  Aluminium doesn't work! and the CB needs to be connected electrically to the ground plane,  If you mount the CB on the roof bars it will try to use the roof as ground plane, not the bar.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Jake on February 09, 2006, 21:18:28
I used to have a aerial on my roof bars.
I connected a wire to the bottom of the aerial and ran it to a grub screw, just behind the roof bar.
Not the best idea, drilling into your roof but the cb worked great.
 :?
 :D
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Tyke on February 10, 2006, 08:37:39
Quote
pretty good skip by any definition, what was the rx quality like


Good mate - S6, R7'ish - on good days hitting the red and into 9-10  :wink:


Quote
A CB ariel needs a decent ground plane ie a large flat bit of steel. Aluminium doesn't work!


Hence all the advice about hooking everything down to the chassis/block to maintain a good RF ground.


Well I must admit, you've got me going again now, might just pull the old rigs out and hook 'em up again. Might even renew my vhf 2m license for mobile ops.

[!Expletive Deleted!] - I can see some spend coming on - better not tell SWMBO - ended up with a 27' antenna and a 4 element Yagi beam on the house roof last time :twisted:
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 10, 2006, 12:18:57
Right then. I have had an idea. Plan 2 as it were.

What if I were to make a hole in the bracket that hooks onto the roof bars and put a bolt through it and attatch a piece of wire. Then make another hole in the roof gutter and bolt on a solder less connector like these jobbies http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/electrical-solderless-terminals-connectors-200pcs_W0QQitemZ7589487790QQcategoryZ41499QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem and then when I take the aerial off I can unplug it and then plug it back in again easily and quickly. Yes down side is that it may pull off by a twig or 2 but I cant think of anything else that would be able to mount to the gutter and be quick to undo. If it isnt quick to undo I wont ever end up using the radio as I am a self confessed lazy arse!

My other idea is. I am wanting to put in a 3 way cigarette lighter socket in the map holder above the sun visor to power the radio as I think the radio will go in the elastic map holder when in use. What if I were to attatch an earth wire to a cigarette lighter plug so I can just plug it into the socket? Obviousley I wouldnt wire in a live wire to the plug!

What size wire would I need to earth it?
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: hobbit on February 10, 2006, 12:29:32
Actually I just use a little mag mount on the roof, and run the cable through the door rubber, only use it for laning reallyu, so plenty of range there

The rack protects it mainly bit if challenged by an oak tree the mag will fall over.

Depending on where you want the signal to generate, ie you are in the front and want a strong signal behind you a front mounted areial is best, and vice versa if you are at the back
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 10, 2006, 12:38:09
Everyone said to me buy a cb radio they are easy to use and great fun, yeah dead easy. Now I have got one all this stuff comes out of the wood work like licenses and mounting points and earths and signals forwards or backwards of you.

I DONT KNOW????????

I just want an aerial that I can take on and off very quickly that I can use for when I do lanes so I can chat to other people no matter where I am in the convoy and possibly to chat to lorry drivers when on a long journey and I am bored!
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: TimM on February 10, 2006, 12:41:04
As hobbit said then, mag mount.

Put your power cord onto a cigarette lighter plug, have a mag mount for the aerial.

1) Open door
2) put CB down
3) plug into cigarette lighter
4) place aerial on roof
5) shut door

Removal reverse the above, it a 20 second job (in or out).
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 10, 2006, 12:52:16
I was going to go with a mag mount but Matt_h used to have a mag mount and every time he went under a tree it fell off and spent more time putting it back on the roof than he did talking! I want a quick easy way to mount it and so it doesnt fall off. If the cigarette lighter for the earth will work that sounds like my solution.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: NeilWilson on February 10, 2006, 13:25:21
Remember though this is for CB, not for intercontinental usage.
You could always try bolting it on as you want, measure the SWR & see if you can get a decent reading then make it a semi-permanent fixture as required.

Neil
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Tyke on February 10, 2006, 13:54:17
Don't let us trouble you MuddyJ old chap - it's only a cb when all said and done.

The guys have told you what works and what is quick to set up mate. Try it first, then make it more permanent if required. If it dont work well then get back and tell us. Someone will be sure to put you right  :wink:
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: TimM on February 10, 2006, 14:20:20
Quote from: "muddyjames"
every time he went under a tree it fell off


I used a mag mount for ages, and yes it did get knocked off by trees sometimes, it depends on how strong your magnet is  :wink:  mine used to get knocked off occasionally, but if I came to a particularly tree lined section I moved it to the back bumper, which was fine for range to nearby vehicles  :D
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Wanderer on February 10, 2006, 15:10:24
I wouldn't use anything as an earth that went steel ally. It'll cause the ally to rot in no time.

Have a look under your rear wheel arch where the rear quarter panel (ally) bolts to the rear mud flap mount (steel) it's always corroded and that's just down to the two materials touching each other.

I always run a good earth up to the roof rack for the lights and antennae.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 10, 2006, 15:50:39
Quote from: "Wanderer"
I wouldn't use anything as an earth that went steel ally. It'll cause the ally to rot in no time.

Have a look under your rear wheel arch where the rear quarter panel (ally) bolts to the rear mud flap mount (steel) it's always corroded and that's just down to the two materials touching each other.

I always run a good earth up to the roof rack for the lights and antennae.


So what are sugesting I do? Not to mount the quick release bracket onto the roof bars? Remember it wont be a permenant fixture hopefully.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Wanderer on February 10, 2006, 16:28:46
You just need to bond over the bit where the alluminium contacts with the steel if that's the electrical path used.
As previously noted there are some high voltages at work when you're transmitting.

Stick a flourescent tube close to the antenna when you're transmitting.

That's how the little lights worked stuck on the end of an antenna (DV27 usually)
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Damonski on February 10, 2006, 20:45:31
.... and a license is a must have, its only a few quid

http://www.ofcom.org.uk/static/archive/ra/publication/ra_info/ra246/ra246.htm

quotation from above link:
Quote

What is CB Radio

CB is a short range radio service for both hobby and business use. It is designed to be used without the need to have any technical qualifications and not to cause interference to other radio users. Hence, only radios meeting certain specific requirements may be used. Antennas need to conform to clause 4 of the licence.

To use CB, you either need to hold a licence yourself or be directly supervised by a licence holder. However, we do offer exemptions to Scouts, Girl Guides and OAP networks, etc.

Do I need a CB licence?

Unless you are using CB radio under the direct supervision of another CB licence-holder, you will need to take out a CB licence in your own name. Please note that children under the age of 14 years cannot hold a CB licence.

How much does a CB licence cost?

The licence currently costs £15 per year, free to those 21 years of age and younger and from 1 April 2001 free to those aged 75 years and older, no matter how many sets or channels you use.


also:
http://www.ofcom.org.uk/static/archive/ra/publication/ra_info/ra369.htm
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 10, 2006, 20:58:33
the license is already done. money came out my account today! last thing I wanna do is get fined for no damn license :D
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Jake on February 10, 2006, 21:15:26
Do we need a licence then?
 :?
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Damonski on February 10, 2006, 21:20:17
Yes, unless you are under 21 or over 75, you need a license, operating a CB radio without a valid license is against the law.
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Jake on February 10, 2006, 21:32:24
Who Polices it though?
All the channels are dead.
 :?
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Damonski on February 10, 2006, 21:41:00
I think its all part of Radio Communications Agency / ofcom now.

You can be reported for not having a license, if and when they investigate the report and you are found not having a license, its a maximum of £5000 and/or imprisonment for 6 months more if it goes to court.

Have a read under the abuse information.  As without a license you fall under CB radio abuse.

http://www.ofcom.org.uk/static/archive/ra/publication/ra_info/ra344.htm
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 11, 2006, 10:35:54
So if we dob someone in do we gat a reward as we could make some money here!!!  :lol:

I wouldnt do that to you Jake, honest   :D
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Jake on February 11, 2006, 12:20:44
Quote from: "muddyjames"
So if we dob someone in do we gat a reward as we could make some money here!!!  :lol:

I wouldnt do that to you Jake, honest   :D


Myself and the thousands too.
Could make a tidy profit (of doom)
 :wink:
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Jake on February 11, 2006, 12:33:30
Now sorted  :wink:
I was going to use a loop hole to not pay for it, by regestering the licence in My daughters name.
She's 15 so it would be free.
But, sod it.
Its now payed for.
 :x
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Damonski on February 11, 2006, 13:32:59
Quote from: "Jake"
Now sorted  :wink:
I was going to use a loop hole to not pay for it, by regestering the licence in My daughters name.
She's 15 so it would be free.
But, sod it.
Its now payed for.
 :x


hehe :) That would only work if every time you used it she was next to you supervising your operation of the radio equipment  :lol:
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: muddyjames on February 11, 2006, 13:50:51
And I thought I was tight fisted Jake!!! I have been known to be tighter than a ducks arse when it comes to money but that idea you had was a; cunning but b; in the ducks arse category! Dont think it was to the level of a devil ducks arse though!
Title: Roof bars. will they conduct electricity?
Post by: Jake on February 11, 2006, 16:37:51
Quote from: "Damo"
Quote from: "Jake"
Now sorted  :wink:
I was going to use a loop hole to not pay for it, by regestering the licence in My daughters name.
She's 15 so it would be free.
But, sod it.
Its now payed for.
 :x


hehe :) That would only work if every time you used it she was next to you supervising your operation of the radio equipment  :lol:


She is with us all the time (well, at the moment. I'm sure that'll change soon)
I always look for an easy way out.
Never mind.
 :D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal